The Gospel Coalition Could Learn a Thing or Two from ‘Disobedient Women’ by Sarah Stankorb.

 

“I hope this book not only does you justice but also helps create the justice you seek.” Sarah Stankorb


TGC believes that social media is a “spiritual distortion zone.”

Recently, TGC posted Social Media Is a Spiritual Distortion Zone. It was the usual rant about social media, followed by a tutorial on how to be spiritual on social media.

Social media acts as a spiritual and cognitive distortion machine that warps our view of reality and bends our will away from God. It’s the systematic, corporately incentivized inversion of Romans 12:1–2. Instead of our minds being renewed by the Spirit of Christ, they’re shaped by algorithmically curated delivery of the particular patterns of the world that best play to our unsanctified desires. They beckon us into conformity with the world by drawing our hearts and minds away from God.

Social media isn’t a neutral player in our sanctification. It’s an active agent working against our becoming more like Christ.

…This doesn’t mean social media is entirely irredeemable

On that note, the author discusses how to change social media. He hopes to see:

  • Discipleship through content creation: producing local digital media that keeps people connected to their local congregation.
  • Replacing influencers with missionaries: For example: Elijah Lamb (@doctrinewithlamb), a young Christian TikToker who regularly takes on tough doctrinal questions for his audience of over 70,000 on a platform more friendly to those leaving faith than those keeping it
  • Curating the good, the true, and the beautiful: He lets us know he is doing this: I  have tried to do this with both a Spotify playlist containing over 100 hours of music and podcasts to help someone reconstruct their faith and a website curating documents from church history for devotional and intellectual growth.
  • Resisting by leaving: For some, the answer really is to delete your social media.

Abuse appears to be a spiritual distortion to be ardently ignored by the theodudes of TGC

This very social media outfit, The Gospel Coalition, should use itself as an example of a social media distortion. I began blogging in 2009. During that time, Paige Patterson had a hall dedicated to him at SEBTS. I called for his resignation, but the gospel boys supported anything that went on at seminaries. Recently, his name was taken off the hall.

Then there was Mark Driscoll. Deeper-thinking Christians realized that he was a travesty. I was one and wrote about it. The Gospel Coalition BFFs couldn’t get enough of him. He wrote posts for the outfit, and many ran to conferences where he was featured as a main speaker. His angry rhetoric, often directed at what he called “effeminate” men while instructing wives to provide certain sexual favors, was over the top. I questioned him for years and put up with sarcastic comments from the boys while hoping to get my message across.

Then there was CJ Mahaney and his failed experiment at Sovereign Grace Churches while apparently covering up child sexual abuse. I spoke up for the victim and was accused of libel by Joe Carter, who recently left social media, saying he was “sorry” if he offended people. Joe, you did and you need to apologize directly to lots of people but being a Calvinist means never having to say you’re sorry.” Along with other advocates, I stood firm, documenting the alleged abuse and following Mahaney’s antics as he fled to Kentucky and sucked in Al Mohler for a while.

Eventually, The Gospel Coalition would become embarrassed by the #metoo #churchtoo movement.

Many of us persisted in reporting sexual abuse in the Southern Baptist Convention, along with just about every other denomination. We were attacked, ridiculed, and accused of not even being Christians. We still persisted, and something began to happen. While The Gospel Coalition ignored us, the #metoo and #churchtoo movements gained steam. Just about every gospel boy put out some lame statement that they were “against abuse.” Crocodile tears were shed, and the superficiality of their “support” was apparent. The breadth and depth of the evangelical scandal were stunning, and secular and Christian media began to take notice.

Disobedient Women by Sarah Stankorb 

Hearing that my name would be in a book caused me some anxiety. I love hiding behind my computer screen and sharing my thoughts. But I decided to trust a principled journalist. Sarah Stankorb wrote truthfully about my foray into the blogging world. I loved reading about others I know as friends, like Christa Brown, Julie Anne Smith, and Amy Smith. However, I learned something new and unexpected. I didn’t realize that we helped journalists to be able to report abuse.

Wartburg Watch covered the extreme theologies of popular pastors and broke abuse cases journalists couldn’t touch. It is immensely difficult for reproters to get editorial approval on a story about sex abuse allegations without charges; it requires deep fact-checking, a willing editor, and a publication taking on a potential liability risk. But reporters have more readily covered the fact of a blog post making such claims, and in this way, Parsons helped create an end-around for getting media coverage of the stories she worked to corroborate. This is especially important given that the average age at which survivors of child abuse repot is fifty-two, often putting them outside the statute of limitation for criminal charges.

I had no idea! I feel compelled to keep writing on these topics even though I am not a writer by training. I think of myself as a simple kitchen table hacker. When I write a story, it is my way of saying, “I believe you.  I didn’t understand that our posts were important when I got calls from major news outlets to ask me for comments. Even now, my heart rate kicks up when a reporter asks to interview me. I do it to help victims get the attention and compassion they deserve, even when my hands are trembling.

Special thanks to Stankorb for believing my story. My friend, Janet, was pleased that she was believed as well.

Final thoughts

When will The Gospel Coalition tell the truth about social media? Yes, there is tough stuff out there. The names I’ve been called are brutal at times. However, I am a Christian and have held onto my faith during the rocky times. When I tell a story of a victim in a church, I see Jesus, who calls Himself “the Truth.” It distresses me to see churches and pastors who do not tell the truth, especially when it involves sex abuse.

Christians are warned so frequently about the evils of “social media” because many leaders:

  • Are afraid of the light shining on them and their church. It is too hard to admit to the truth.
  • Feel the average Christian is stupid, unlike the leaders of The Gospel Coalition, who are all whiz kids.
  • Do not want the riff-raff in the pews to discover the abuse hidden from them because they will get mad and leave, but the leaders need their money.

The next time The Gospel Coalition wishes to publish another “ho-hum” screed about social media, they should try to tell the truth. After all, aren’t they a social media outfit raising money for their enterprise?

PS Thanks go out to Sarah Standkorb, who so carefully told the truth about my small contribution to fighting abuse. You are now officially a member of “The Daughter of Stan.”

 

Comments

The Gospel Coalition Could Learn a Thing or Two from ‘Disobedient Women’ by Sarah Stankorb. — 48 Comments

  1. Just once ;-),

    it would be nice if TGC stepped out of their self-created social media distortion zone and were able see and respond to the abuse the way Christians SHOULD, instead of the way they do, which is to sanction by their silence things that should never be inside their clique.

  2. “The next time The Gospel Coalition wishes to publish another ‘ho-hum’ screed about social media, they should try to tell the truth. After all, aren’t they a social media outfit raising money for their enterprise?

    “PS Thanks go out to Sarah Stankorb, who so carefully told the truth about my small contribution to fighting abuse.”

    Ordered the book from Amazon but not quite finished 1st read – it’s a keeper, along with “Jesus and John Wayne” and “The Making of Biblical Womanhood”, and of course, following TWW. Essential reading. Excellent work from Sarah Stankorb. @sarahstankorb sarahstankorb.com

    News to Theobros, like the Gospel boys network: Social Media ain’t going away. God gave us the Internet so for Heaven’s sake, we’re all going to put it to good use, walking in the Light. As much as a Sunday morning preacher can rant, as some have always done, women can tell what really goes on. To the world. Light.

    1 John 1 completely supports Social Media on the Internet: “This is the message which we have heard from him and announce to you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all. If we say that we have fellowship with him and walk in the darkness, we lie, and don’t tell the truth. But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus Christ, his Son, cleanses us from all sin.”

    Lots of light is happening via the Internet over Social Media.

    Sarah Stankorb mentions this in her book. She terms it a Reformation – women telling the truth using Social Media on the Internet.

    Thank God, ’bout time.

  3. Ava Aaronson,

    Along the lines of walking in the light, to paraphrase: “deeds done in darkness will be shouted from the rooftops”.

    Sounds rather scriptural if you ask me, but maybe not the type of scriptural TGC likes to be involved in. However, since their BFF’s deeds seem to be shouted from today’s equivalent of rooftops (the Internet), you would think they might be interested in being on the side of truth and decrying the corruption in the church. But maybe in their eyes truth is just an outdated concept not valid for these times.

  4. God bless the kitchen table hackers and the journalists who reach out to them.
    And God bless abuse overcomers who know better than to try to shout into the echo chambers of groups like the Gospel Coalition.

  5. Afterburne, you are absolutely right that “TGC should step out of self-created social media distortion zone….” Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening anytime soon when they carefully ignore debacles such as endorsing Josh Butler’s book. It appears the article created quite a backlash; see https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2023/may/joshua-butler-resign-tgc-beautiful-union-redemption-tempe-c.html. How long will it take before TGC collapses in on itself, as did T4G?

  6. “I feel compelled to keep writing on these topics even though I am not a writer by training. I think of myself as a simple kitchen table hacker.”

    This is one of the things (in addition to your enormous heart and willing ears) that makes you so approachable, Dee.

    Moses and Paul didn’t think of themselves as eloquent, either 🙂

  7. Old Timer: How long will it take before TGC collapses in on itself, as did T4G?

    Consider the work of Jeff Guinn, a writer who researches and publishes the truth about demagogues, from their start to their finish, as each one experiences the: “collapse in on itself”.

  8. There are those who stand up for people being persecuted.
    The ones who stand up are far more eloquent than they know.
    Ask the people they have helped.

    Sometimes ‘eloquence’ is simply confronting bullying head-on.

  9. Amy Smith,

    That chapter title was my favorite part of the book. You were there from the beginning! Little did that awful man know his mistake would be remembered far more than anything he said.

  10. I guess that in the midst of such horrible, tragic stories we have to find humor to keep our sanity. I hope that explains why I’ve always chuckled at the “Daughter of Stan” reference. It is the result of a hastily thrown, venomous charge, which unintentionally reveals more about the soul who hurled it than about the intended target. It never fails to bring a smile. God’s blessings to the official order of “The Daughters of Stan”.

  11. Abuse appears to be a spiritual distortion to be ardently ignored by the theodudes of TGC

    PRIVILEGE OF PASTORAL RANK.
    “TOUCH NOT MINE ANOINTED!”

  12. His angry rhetoric, often directed at what he called “effeminate” men

    Cut the Proper Code Words.
    What these CHRISTIAN Andrew Tates are saying is “FAAAG! FAAAAAAAG!! FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAG!!!”.

  13. When will The Gospel Coalition tell the truth about social media?

    NEVER.
    God’s Special Pets Can Do No Wrong.

  14. Sarah (aka Wild Honey),

    Some who are talented and even well trained writers should be ashamed of themselves for not using their remarkable gifts to speak the truth in love and also to expose horrendous evil which needs to be brought to light. God bless Dee!

  15. 2 things. Dee i bet even the pugs arw proud of you!!! AND coming from a calvinist perspective…dont these guys have to believe these blogs are ALL GODS WILL!!!!

  16. BD: God bless the kitchen table hackers

    Back in the early 2000s it was a similar thing with the bloggers (who were accused of doing their thing from their mother’s basement, in their pajamas) that blew the lid off of things the mainstream media wouldn’t touch. Go hackers!

  17. Dee, when I read this……. the parts about your trembling hands, kitchen table hacker stuff, the way the Christian Industrial Complex treated you……. and helping journalists be able to report abuse……
    I thought of Isaiah 6:8……. When God burdened the hearts of a few people to step up and to speak the truth and expose what’s happening in churches, you said “Here am I. Send me.” …… and the work you do is a labor of love and true concern.

    I very much suspect when (and if) the TGC boys, and many more like them, heard the call, they said, “Here am I. Pay me!”

  18. Thank you all for your kind comments. This is a little difficult for me because I have always wanted the focus to be on the victims. I don’t do so well being the focus but that’s just my thing. Thank you from the bottom of my heart. I never thought people would be reading me, let alone complimenting me.It is ll a surprise.

  19. StillWiggling,

    I remember those days. Whenever I would meet people face to face, I would hand them a bag of Cheetos as a nod to that. I need to start that again.

  20. Abigail,

    Buttercup, Tulip, and Poppy send their regards. I do find it amusing that this non-Calvinist has been the one to deal with the new Calvinist crowd. Yep-it was God’s design, so they need to deal with it.

  21. Sarah (aka Wild Honey),

    I try so hard to be approachable. The stories that folks share with me are hard to express. I explain that I have heard it all, and they need to be at peace as they tell me their pain. They have complete control over their stories. Many back out at the last moment, which is fine with me.

  22. Another book I need to order. Thank you Dee (and Todd) for all you bring to light here. In Proverbs 6, where God lists the things He hates (HATES) lying is listed twice. Yet so many pastors and leaders have no problem doing it. SMH

  23. Nancy2(aka Kevlar): Dee, when I read this……. the parts about your trembling hands, kitchen table hacker stuff, the way the Christian Industrial Complex treated you……. and helping journalists be able to report abuse……
    I thought of Isaiah 6:8……. When God burdened the hearts of a few people to step up and to speak the truth and expose what’s happening in churches, you said “Here am I. Send me.” …… and the work you do is a labor of love and true concern.

    That. Only I hadn’t thought of Isaiah 6:8. 🙂 And quoting an out-of-context response:

    Isaiah 6:9 (KJV) And he [the Lord] said, Go [Dee], and tell this people….

  24. Nancy2(aka Kevlar):

    “Here am I.Pay me!”

    Ha! I am sure that some probably did begin that way.

    I would like to think most didn’t. However, purity of initial motivation hardly matters when so very many still end up ignoring blatant sin at the highest levels of (not-servant) leadership and are really just following money.

    A plague be upon those who ignore and are silent about the vulnerable and victimized.

  25. Haven’t the Gospel Coalition heard how cults control the information their members are allowed to see and in fact all interactions with outsiders?
    Hassan’s BITE model would be interesting to compare this with.

  26. Sarah (aka Wild Honey): This is one of the things (in addition to your enormous heart and willing ears) that makes you so approachable, Dee.

    If there’s a bustle in your hedgerow
    Don’t be alarmed now
    It’s just a spring clean for the May Queen…

  27. I agree the breathless angst of the TGC quotes is a little much. But I can’t tell from the snippets here what they’re actually worried about. Is it information the powers that be don’t want known? Or is this a Christianified version of popular concern about how social media affects people?

    I’ve read about 3/4 of Stankorb’s book, and many of the stories involve watchblogging, with some Twitter activism (#churchtoo). Ancient history, in internet time. Social media in 2023 is not the same as the blogosphere of the early aughts, or even Twitter in 2018. It’s a big business whose users are the product. The big platforms are built to be attention-sucking vortexes. They are full of rabbit holes to genuinely ugly places.

    I don’t think any Instagram missionaries will be redeeming the algorithms with their CCM playlists. But there’s plenty of reasons to suspect social media, as it exists now, is not good for people. So… I might actually agree with TGC a little bit here *le gasp*

  28. Nancy2(aka Kevlar),

    “I very much suspect when (and if) the TGC boys, and many more like them, heard the call, they said, “Here am I. Pay me!””
    ++++++++++++++++++++

    and “Here am I. Publish me.”

    Double standards, in action, because it benefits him.

    Uneven scales in action, because it benefits him.
    .
    .
    i observed at least one up&coming influencer-pastor promote how The Gospel Coalition published him by tweeting about it. He has since taken down the tweet.

    But his article is still there, along with other articles he’s written.

    His article was in response to The Southern Baptist Convention Executive Committee’s Response to Sexual Abuse Allegations and an Audit of the Procedures and Actions of the Credentials Committee, dated May 15, 2022

    It was a good article. His subject headings were:

    Don’t Look Away
    Don’t Downplay
    Don’t Be Silent
    Don’t Walk Away

    Set apart from the rest of the text in bold was,

    “This is the hour to speak up, to refuse to yield, to fight for the justice/mercyGod requires of us”
    .
    .

    Has he challenged his benefactor (TGC) and their response to credible abuse at Sovereign Grace Ministries with this same advocacy?

    Or does he let it slide so he can benefit from their promotion?

  29. To try and give some perspective, hear what Spurgeon says of the woman and her alabaster box of precious ointment.
    “When you do the best you can from the purest motives and your Lord accepts your service, do not expect that others will approve all your actions. There was never a more beautiful proof of love to Christ than this anointing at Bethany, yet the disciples found fault with it. As they could not object to the action itself, they objected another thing would have been better. There is a great deal of that kind of wisdom in the world. But if we wait until we learn that wisdom, we will never do anything for our Lord. If this devoted and enthusiastic woman had waited for the advice of these prudent people, she would neither have sold the ointment nor poured it out. She did well to take counsel with her own loving heart and then to pour the precious oil on that dear head that was so soon to be crowned with thorns. She thus showed that at least one heart in the world thought nothing was too good for her Lord, and the best of the best ought to be given to Him. May she have many imitators in every age until Jesus comes again!”

  30. John Berry:
    Haven’t the Gospel Coalition heard how cults control the information their members are allowed to see and in fact all interactions with outsiders?
    Hassan’s BITE model would be interesting to compare this with.

    Remember, Berry:

    Christians define CULT entirely by Theological Correctness, nitpicked through an electron microscope.
    Not through behavior towards their people.
    And especially Not repeat NOT through such Heathen Secular Humanist methods as the BITE model.

  31. It often seems to me that professional christian public speakers, such as tend to feature here in Wartburg, want to be famous until they don’t. By the same token, they love the power of social media until they don’t. Regular Wartburgers * will probably interpret this as meaning that public speakers like to be in control of the narrative.

    Long-term regular Wartburgers may remember a certain discussion thread a few years back. I can’t remember what it was now (and site:thewartburgwatch.com on google isn’t helping!), but a preacher of some species or other bungeed in and, if I may be blunt, patronised everybody with theatrical language. I remember he used the phrase “The baked confection comes out delicious” in the context of cinnamon rolls. (Sigh.) His staged and over-authored contributions strike me, even now, as a wasted opportunity, because I think that he could have made some really good points if only he’d been willing to drop the act and engage actual people in actual conversation.

    ISTM that preaching tends to corrupt, and absolute preaching corrupts absolutely.

    * available with or without fries

  32. Lowlandseer: She thus showed that at least one heart in the world thought nothing was too good for her Lord, and the best of the best ought to be given to Him. May she have many imitators in every age until Jesus comes again!”

    I agree.

  33. CMT,

    It’s convenient for them to say this. I think it was unwise of anyone small to use “platforms” instead of blogs, but TGC publish a plethora of thinly argued books and glossy looking articles. TGC are big and the rest of us are small.