The Hillsong Meltdown Continues: Carl Lentz Resembles Ravi Zacharias, the Messy Kimes Resignation, and Brian Houston Appears Full of it.

Saturn’s rings and northern hemisphere glow bright in this representational color photograph taken by Voyager 2. It’s a combination of three images, taken through ultraviolet, violet and green filters. NASA

“There are those whose primary ability is to spin wheels of manipulation. It is their second skin and without these spinning wheels, they simply do not know how to function. They are like toys on wheels of manipulation and control. If you remove one of the wheels, they’ll never be able to feel secure, be whole.” ― C. JoyBell C.


I am grateful that Todd Wilhelm continues to look into the Bruce Ashford situation. When someone is the Dean at a big-name seminary and an elder and BFF of JD Greear, he must be willing to face the music when something goes wrong. Isn’t he supposed to be a leader? Doesn’t Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary and the Summit have a responsibility to tell folks what happened? Aren’t these folks into “church discipline?” Or maybe they only mean discipline for the “little people.” The leaders get to ride off into the sunset, quietly. What role models!

Hillsong is going for the “prolonged bloodletting” approach.

I have had the unique opportunity (if one can call it that) of watching the meltdown of Mark Driscoll, Willow Creek, Harvest Bible Chapel, along with smaller yet significant church and parachurch ministries. The ones that do it right admit quickly to the scandal and try to get it all at as soon as possible. The “drips and drabs” approach only leads to prolonged bloodletting, and we know what happened in history when bloodletting was the treatment for serious illness. In such a procedure, the patient died, and the blood loss hastened the end.

I think many leaders in Hillsong knew what was going on but chose to ignore it to keep the Hillsong industrial complex afloat. The leaders’ salaries were at stake, and they had begun to enjoy the good life of a celebrity who has lots of money to throw around. Sadly, that money was from the “little people” who trusted the leaders. They believed the hoopla going on upfront and got used.

Here are some of the continuing drips and drabs.

The lying adulterer Carl Lentz channels Ravi Zacharias and loves getting “massages.”

I know that honest, therapeutic massage treatment centers exist. I am not talking about those. The Christian Post wrote: Carl Lentz allegedly ‘caused’ mental illness in multiple staff, volunteers; opens up about affairs: report.

Some of the following information came from an “Internal Investigation Report Regarding Carl Lentz and Other Matters,” which ‘is the result of an internal investigation conducted on behalf of Hillsong Church by the New York City law firm Zukerman Gore Brandeis & Crossman, LLP,’ Here is an overview of their findings.

  • A mishandling of the spiritual care of a vulnerable parishioner with an eating disorder who eventually died.
  • multiple incidents of consensual or non-consensual sexual interaction between church leaders and congregants, staff, volunteers, or non-churchgoers.
  • It presents an unflattering view of Lentz as a lying, massage-loving, adulterer who presided over a congregation in which he did as he pleased in a hierarchy where he seemingly answered to no one.
  • it appears that effective management and accountability of Lentz was nonexistent.
  • Staffers and volunteers found Lentz so challenging and manipulative, they allege that he “caused” them to suffer from mental illness.
  • Lentz was a younger version of Brian Houston.
  • One former ministry leader who accused of having “a history of sleeping around with women in the church” and once accused of receiving sexual favors from someone while he was “getting high.”
  • [Redacted] stated that Lentz once yelled at him for ‘breathing too loud’ while he was driving,”

Read the following quote carefully and see if you catch it.

Lentz told investigators that he only yelled when the servant almost crashed into someone on Bowery Street in Manhattan and that drivers did not have to be available 24/7.

The servant?????? Wut?

Is Lentz mimicking Rave Zacharias? 

Lentz … described receiving frequent massages, though he would not admit to them being sexual in nature but…
…in 2019 the routine of Lentz receiving massages became more of a night time occurrence. Review of Lentz’s text messages showed masseuses quoting Lentz for the cost of massages and also other sexual acts, but it was unclear from the text messages if Lentz received only massages from these women or something more,”

Carl Lentz figures in the resignation of Josh and Leona Kimes from Boston Hillsong.

From the above Christian Post

“Such efforts included boldly lying to his wife, Laura, when she caught him and Leona [Kimes] in flagrante delecto on a couch late at night,” investigators said.

Julie Roys reported Josh and Leona Kimes Resign from Hillsong Boston. When I first heard about this resignation, it suggested that Josh and Leona Kimes wanted out because they were fed up with Hillsong. Perhaps they were, but the story goes far deeper than that.

the Kimes have themselves come under scrutiny for their treatment of volunteers in Boston. In 2020, Tiffany Perez, a former volunteer there, told Business Insider that she was asked to care for the couple’s daughter for up to 25 hours a week, as well as clean their house and look after their dog, while being paid $150 a week.

However, Kimes claims Lentz sexually assaulted her.

“Such efforts included boldly lying to his wife, Laura, when she caught him and Leona (Kimes) in flagrante delecto on a couch late at night,” The Christian Post said, quoting investigators.

“Carl said (Lentz and Leona) would do ‘pretty much everything you could do’ without engaging in oral sex or intercourse,” investigators said.

“One night in 2016, while at the home of former NBA player Tyson Chandler, Kimes and Lentz were once caught in the act by Laura Lentz, who was accused of punching Kimes two or three times in the face,”

…The investigators noted in the report the power dynamic between Lentz and Leona Kimes and concluded it was “unlikely that Leona was capable of achieving the distance necessary to exercise true choice,” according to The Christian Post.

However, for the fuller story, we must consider this situation: Hillsong Boston Pastor Josh Kimes Resigns, Admits to Sending Racist Text to Colleagues

“Josh Kimes admitted that he once wrote a racist text. He explained that he apologized to each of the people who received the text. Outside of that, he stated the other allegations of racism were half-truths or lies,” the investigators explained. “Leona Kimes stated that if there was racism at Hillsong, it was Carl Lentz’s fault. Leona stated that each time they wanted to have a meeting or organize an event related to racism, Lentz would tell them that he would handle it and then never do anything.”

Layers upon layers…

Hillsong leader thinks Brian Houston is “full of it.”

The Christian Post reported: Hillsong exec. called Brian Houston’s explanation after visiting woman’s hotel room ‘dribble’:

A high-level Hillsong Church executive ( John Mays) dismissed founder Brian Houston’s explanation for why he visited the hotel room of an unidentified woman for 40 minutes during the church’s annual conference in 2019 as insulting “dribble” just days before Houston resigned, a leaked letter suggests.

…Houston violated Hillsong’s pastoral code of conduct by entering the hotel room of the unidentified woman for 40 minutes while under the influence of alcohol and prescription drugs during the church’s annual conference in 2019.

Here’s the kicker:

Houston doesn’t recall having sex with the woman, and the woman has not said if they had sex.

That woman resigned from Hillsong. I wonder if money had anything to do with this?

And in the “layer upon layer” department:

Mays, whose son Jason Mays pleaded guilty to indecent assault of former Hillsong College student Anna Crenshaw in January 2020,

Isn’t it curious how these women all seem to resign?

“One insulting example (of many) is that Brian lost his room key so knocked on the lady’s door, a detail he no doubt recalls despite memory loss during the following 40 minutes. Are we really asking our staff to accept such dribble and defend our Church with such?” he asked.

Hillsong Church also revealed in March that Houston exchanged an “inappropriate text message” with a church staffer in 2013. According to Dooley, the text message was “along the lines of, ‘If I was with you I would like to give you a kiss and a cuddle or a hug.’” The staffer resigned shortly after. Hillsong Church blamed Houston’s actions in this case on “sleeping tablets.”

Bobbie Houston was fired. She was paid a significant amount of money if I’m reading this correctly, and she seemed to ignore the issues surrounding her hubby.

Earlier this month, Hillsong Church also fired Bobbie Houston. Mays, in his letter, had also recommended that she be held accountable.

“I believe Bobbie in her capacity as Global Senior Pastor, paid accordingly, should also be accountable for her willingness to tolerate such behavior and defiance on the part of her co-leader,” Mays wrote. “I do not see her as a victim in this situation, she has a biblical, professional and corporate responsibility to ensure accountability.”

Oh, I guess I should say that Carl Lentz and Brian Houston deny and excuse this, that, and whatever.

Final Note

I think they should close it down, but they won’t—too many layers upon layers of businesses with money.  My guess is that there are more revelations to come.

Comments

The Hillsong Meltdown Continues: Carl Lentz Resembles Ravi Zacharias, the Messy Kimes Resignation, and Brian Houston Appears Full of it. — 39 Comments

  1. Ted,

    I just heard the best name yet for the new celebrity pastors with no accountability. “Pastor Warlords.”

  2. Dribble means balderdash, nonsense, rubbish, and is an informal use of those words in British, South African, Australian cultures.
    US informal (formal – balderdash) would be something like crap or drivel.

  3. Dee, Mark Twain said the difference between truth and fiction is that fiction has to be believable.

    For example: “Houston doesn’t recall having sex with the woman.”

    I don’t even know what that means. Doesn’t recall? Even Clinton had the guts to give a definite answer: “I did not have sex with that woman…” (All right, it was a lie, but still, more believable that he could say it than that he “couldn’t recall”).

  4. I just googled “pastor warlords.” Wow. That’s really a thing. I thought you were talking about a possible name for a Netflix series.

  5. Their music isn’t all that anyways (my opinion).
    I’d rather go to a Steely Dan concert any day.

  6. dee: “Pastor Warlords.”

    Been there. Seen that.

    When we know it’s time to move on.

    Rom. 12, 1 Cor. 12, Eph. 4. Warlord is not on the list.

    Galatians 5, warlording is not among the fruits of the Spirit.

  7. “knew what was going on but chose to ignore it to keep the Hillsong industrial complex afloat. The leaders’ salaries were at stake, and they had begun to enjoy the good life of a celebrity who has lots of money to throw around. Sadly, that money was from the ‘little people’ who trusted the leaders.”

    Do the duped savor bankrolling an orgy that masquerades as church leadership? How does that feel?

    The problem with tithing. Jesus overturned the businessmen in the House.

    Power aka warlording, vice aka the orgy, $$$ aka tithing. The trifecta of evil enterprise aka “church”.

  8. Muff Potter: Their music isn’t all that anyways (my opinion).

    The Hillsong multitudes go for the performance … period. Music is the primary platform, not the spoken Word. It matters not to them that Hillsong leaders have no character or that they don’t preach the Gospel. Big screens, fog machines, and tight jeans are the draw. The experience of being in a crowd and “worshiping” to the beat of the drum ‘is’ Christianity to Hillsongers. I suppose there is some genuine embedded in the sea of counterfeit, but the latter overwhelms the former (IMO).

  9. “I think they should close it down, but they won’t — too many layers upon layers of businesses with money.” (Dee)

    Preaching cheap grace, merchandising the gospel, book-of-the-month, tax-free church are prosperous endeavors in America. Toss some leaders into the mix who have charisma without character and you are on your way to the bank!

  10. Muff Potter: Their music isn’t all that anyways (my opinion).

    Hillsong would have been only a small blip on the radar if it weren’t for a previous worship leader named Darlene Zschech. Folks sure weren’t drawn to the ministry because of Brian Houston’s preaching. I sensed that Ms. Zschech was the real deal, but she’s been gone for several years (she probably saw what went on behind the curtain and bailed out).

  11. Max:
    . . . . she’s been gone for several years (she probably saw what went on behind the curtain and bailed out).

    Or got tired of not getting recording royalties because Hill$ong takes them. Maybe a bit of both.

    Not that she shouldn’t get royalties for her performances. It is her voice and her talent selling all that music for them after all.

  12. Well “servant” might be the appropriate word if he was hired as such and paid appropriately (annual salaries for a private driver in NYC seem to be around $61,000 though the range might be fairly broad). As for 7 by 24, what hours was he expecting? I can remember reading an old Mrs Beeton’s guide to household management[1] that said that it was very important to respect a chauffeur’s off hours because his getting sufficient rest was essential for safe driving.

    [1] circa 1960, the guide included info on just about everything including how to notify authorities of a death to who was responsible for taxes for part-time workers (this was the UK). It was also for a world where families buying the book hoped to at least be paying for someone to come in weekly to help with house cleaning.

  13. Ted: For example: “Houston doesn’t recall having sex with the woman.”

    He’s trying to lie his way out without saying anything definite that can ACTUALLY BE a lie.
    “DID I ACTUALLY SAY I DID (OR DIDN’T)? IN SO MANY WORDS? HUH? HUH? HUH?”

    Indirect Plausible Deniability worthy of Russian Bureaucracy.
    Or Douggie ESQUIRE of Vision Forum and his airtight definition of “Knowing in a Biblical Sense”.

  14. Ava Aaronson: Performance church. It’s a thing.

    Where the Great God Entertainment sits on the throne. “Hurry, Hurry, Hurry, Step right up to the greatest show on Earth!” shouts the carnival barker.

    “Today we have the astonishing spectacle of millions of dollars being poured into the unholy job of providing earthly entertainment for the so-called sons of heaven. Religious entertainment is in many places rapidly crowding out the serious things of God. Many churches these days have become little more than poor theaters where fifth-rate “producers” peddle their shoddy wares with the full approval of evangelical leaders who can even quote a holy text in defense of their delinquency. And hardly a man dares raise his voice against it.” (A.W. Tozer)

  15. Afterburne: Or got tired of not getting recording royalties because Hill$ong takes them.

    Leonard Ravenhill, back in the day, noted the seamy side of the Christian music industry. Lots of ill will behind those hits. Power, $$$, vice. He knew back then what we’re just finding out now.

    Ravenhill also questioned why churches had music ministers but no prayer ministers; choir rooms but no prayer rooms.

    “Cuz’ you can pray anywhere, no prayer minister needed,” our church leadership said.

    With a new church addition, we insisted on a dedicated prayer chapel. It happened.

  16. Ava Aaronson: Leonard Ravenhill, back in the day, noted the seamy side of the Christian music industry. Lots of ill will behind those hits. Power, $$$, vice. He knew back then what we’re just finding out now.

    Ravenhill also questioned why churches had music ministers but no prayer ministers; choir rooms but no prayer rooms.

    “Cuz’ you can pray anywhere, no prayer minister needed,” our church leadership said.

    With a new church addition, we insisted on a dedicated prayer chapel. It happened.

    Well you’ve got to be careful with that, because a church organization that uses the same initials as International House of Pancakes has a 24×7 “prayer room” in Kansas City, MO. That said, it’s mostly people up front singing in 2 hour shifts while other people are in the room praying. Oh, and all these people raise their support from their families, friends and churches so they can do this for a year or two. So yeah, it’s a 24×7 prayer room, but it’s mostly singing.

  17. Muslin, fka Dee Holmes,

    The IHOP as “Prayer” Performance. It’s a television show, for crying out loud. Lights, camera, action.

    What in heaven’s name! The antithesis of Jesus’ prayer teaching: not before men or an audience, never a performance, 2-3 gathered together maybe, or solo, not gratuitously long – so again, not a performance.

    Anyone can fake anything of “god”. If we had a nickel for each fake, we’d be wealthier than the religious grifters.

    LOL: TV “prayer”. Pathetic.

    Anyway, I doubt IHOP is what Ravenhill had in mind. Definitely not what Jesus had in mind.

    Glad you brought this up. Thx.

  18. Ava Aaronson: Ravenhill also questioned why churches had music ministers but no prayer ministers; choir rooms but no prayer rooms.

    I would also add … performance stages but no prayer altars.

  19. Muslin, fka Dee Holmes: organization that uses

    “You have a spectacle, I have a spectacle, so let us spectacle together*.” – quote by Jeff Sharlet about the National Prayer Breakfast, in the film series, “The Family”.

    Governmental power leaders + Evangelical elites, spectacling together.*

    *The same collaboration executed Jesus.

  20. Max: I would also add … performance stages but no prayer altars.

    So … elevate, but stone the crows, don’t kneel!

    ‘Cuz, as Dee notes, … “warlord pastors”. Or, Jeff Sharlet, in The Family: “wolf-kings”.

  21. Ava Aaronson: Do the duped savor bankrolling an orgy that masquerades as church leadership? How does that feel?

    They have got no savor (haven’t noticed what got trodden underfoot) and no feeling. (That was me, fewer years ago than I’m comfortable admitting!)

    Changed sense of taste. Disease going round like as if it was a meme. Bruce Ashford pointed out that the assembly is supposed to focus on our relating in order to strengthen each other in virtue. Pray for the “salus” of Jerusalem.

  22. FYI- for those who mentioned Darlene Zschech of Hillsong, her and her husband started their own version of Hillsong Chuch, called Hope Unlimited Church. They only have a few franchisees here in the USA. One of them was near us in SoCal, a large independent church that adopted in and then closed a few years later. Not sure how HopeUC compares to Hillsong…

  23. dee,

    I like the term “Pastor Warlords.” That’s SO not my pastor! We had a guest Spanish-speaking deacon today, and everyone was ready to start Mass, but we couldn’t find Father Gary anywhere. Much shrugging and clueless gesticulating of the volunteers. Finally, he came out of the office wing, wandered up to the altar, picked something up, and wandered off again, while everyone shrugged, and the lady doing the announcements repeated a few things – “in case you missed it” – and the choir giggled.

    He eventually turned up again, and we started only five minutes late. He doesn’t have dementia, but he enjoys being a little dotty sometimes, I think, so people will underestimate him.

  24. Cynthia W.: Altars are for sacrifice.

    In former days of Southern Baptist life, there were prayer benches (“altars”) at the front of every church. Steps leading up to the pulpit were also places where folks could kneel to pray. There, they confessed sin, prayed for the sick, prayed for lost family and friends, thanked God for His blessings, etc. Those are things of the past, except perhaps in some rural churches where that tradition continues.

    Offering prayer and praise is a form of sacrifice to the Lord:

    “Let us at all times offer up to God a sacrifice of praise, which is the fruit of lips that thankfully acknowledge and confess and glorify His name” (Hebrews 13:15).

  25. dee: I just heard the best name yet for the new celebrity pastors with no accountability. “Pastor Warlords.”

    Guess I don’t want the phrase “pastor warlord” to gain any currency, since the real-life examples seem to be Charles Taylor and this Joshua Milton Blahyi guy.

    Yeesh. Let’s just keep calling them grifters, please, unless they actively engage in slaughter.

  26. dee: I just heard the best name yet for the new celebrity pastors with no accountability. “Pastor Warlords.”

    Adding to my previous comment, celebrity pastors with no accountability do cause a huge amount of destruction, and I would not want to minimize that. Some of them probably would turn into actual warlords if they believed, or pretended to believe, that a group did not deserve to live.

    There’s a lot of violence in the world right now, and some of it is aligned with churches. So far, calling people “prayer warriors” has not turned church groups into platoons, but I am afraid that some congregations are heading more in that direction. In unstable times, people don’t always know the difference between metaphors and instructions.

    Maybe calling someone a warlord will underscore the bad things they do. Maybe it will give them more ideas (shudder). I guess I’d lean towards a grandiose name not in widespread use, like potentate. Or maybe a made-up title would work, like grand poobah—which apparently made its way from The Mikado to The Flintstones and then to Happy Days, according to that great font of knowledge, Wikipedia.

  27. Max: I would also add … performance stages but no prayer altars.

    Why am I hearing Frankie Goes to Hollywood’s “Relax” when I read this?
    Especially its original music videos that got screened on USA’s Night Flight?
    (MTV would only show the performance video.)

  28. Max: I guarantee you that IHOP and Mike Bickle are a scandal waiting to happen.

    I worked at the Other IHOP’s company headquarters from 1977 to 1982, and they were nothing to brag about either.
    Dark Side of The Dilbert Zone.

  29. Arise Church in NZ which has modelled itself on Hillsong is undergoing its own scandals over the abuse of interns. It seems nothing has changed in the world of celebrity Christendom. I also read your post on John MacArthur and his abuses. Demanding that a women stay with her abusing husband is reprehensible. But I heard similar from the pulpit of the fundamentalist church (cult more accurately) in NZ with one pastor saying it would honour God to stay with her abusive husband even if she were to be killed by him.