Thanks to our friend Todd Wilhelm, we are able to keep track of what is going on half a world away with the Calvinista crowd. Todd just brought to our attention a conference taking place in Dubai which features two members of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary faculty — Tom Schreiner and Bruce Ware. We are grateful that Todd has allowed us to publish his post in its entirety for our readers.
But before we get to our guest post, we believe it is important to provide some background information about these two colleagues. Tom Schreiner and Bruce Ware have much more in common than just their current employer…
According to Tom Schreiner's faculty profile, he holds the following advanced degrees:
Th.M., Western Conservative Baptist Seminary Ph.D., Fuller Theological Seminary
And Bruce Ware's faculty profile indicates that he has these advanced degrees:
M.Div., Th.M., Western Conservative Baptist Seminary; M.A., University of Washington; Ph.D., Fuller Theological Seminary
If Western (Conservative Baptist) Seminary sounds familiar, it's probably because we mentioned Mark Driscoll's educational background in a previous post. You may recall that he holds a Master of Arts degree from Western Seminary. Perhaps this connection is why Bruce Ware preached at Mars Hill Church back in 2013.
Not only did Schreiner and Ware earn degrees from the same institutions, but they taught at the same seminaries. Take a look…
Dr. Schreiner joined the Southern faculty in 1997 after serving 11 years on the faculty at Bethel Theological Seminary.
Dr. Ware is a highly esteemed theologian and author in the evangelical world. He came to Southern Seminary from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School where he served as Chairman of the Department of Biblical and Systematic Theology. Prior to this, he taught at Western Conservative Baptist Seminary and Bethel Theological Seminary.
Bruce Ware began teaching at Bethel Seminary in 1984 and, if you do the math above, Schreiner began teaching at Bethel Seminary around 1986. Ware was still teaching at Bethel in 1986, so it appears they were colleagues there. Ware also taught at his alma mater (Western Seminary) and later at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (TEDS).
After eleven years at Bethel, Tom Schreiner joined the faculty at Southern Seminary (in 1997). The following year, Bruce Ware left TEDS and joined the SBTS faculty. (link)
The Evangelical Theological Society (ETS) is also a point of commonality. Bruce Ware served as president of the Evangelical Theological Society in 2008, and Tom Schreiner served as ETS president in 2014. (link)
These two men have written extensively about their theological beliefs. Bruce Ware, a proponent of ESS (Eternal Subordination of the Son to the Father), wrote Tampering with the Trinity, Does the Son Submit to His Father? which appeared in the Journal of Biblical Manhood and Womanhood in 2001 (link) You can read the article in its entirety on the CBMW website. By the way, Ware's son-in-law Owen Strachan is the current CBMW president, a position Bruce Ware previously held. Wade Burleson and Paul Burleson (Wade's father) have taken issue with ESS here and here.
When Tom Schreiner was teaching at Bethel Seminary, he wrote articles that were featured in the tome Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, published in 1991 and edited by John Piper and Wayne Grudem.
Speaking of Piper and Grudem, they were in seminary together for a season and taught together at Bethel College. Can you imagine Piper, Grudem, Schreiner, and Ware together in Minneapolis at the same time?! Subsequent to teaching at Bethel College, John Piper was called to pastor Bethlehem Baptist Church in 1980, and the remaining three (Grudem, Schreiner, and Ware) taught at Bethel presumably during overlapping years.
No doubt there are more connections between these birds of a feather, which we will probably delve into at a later date.
And now, Todd's post…
Further Evidence of Dubai's Connection to C.J. Mahaney (link)
– Todd Wilhelm
Almost 2 years have passed since I resigned my membership at UCCD (United Christian Church of Dubai) over issues of conscience. I was opposed to the promotion (on occasion from the pulpit) and sales of books authored by C.J. Mahaney due to his involvement in covering up and enabling the sexual abuse of children in the Sovereign Grace churches.
You can read my story on The Wartburg Watch blog.
When I was a member of UCCD I had numerous conversations with several of the pastors concerning C.J. Mahaney. Their response to me was that Mahaney and the sexual abuse scandal he was involved in was an American problem, it had nothing to do with us in Dubai. I wasn’t buying what they were selling. Here is an email I wrote to Assistant Pastor Richard Ngwisha on 23 February 2013, about 2 weeks prior to my resignation.
Unfortunately this SGM crisis is not simply a denominational crisis, nor is it contained within the USA. The fact that the T4G leaders continue to allow Mahaney to speak at conferences and either publicly endorse his ministry or remain silent in the face of mounting charges of sexual abuse and cover-up is shameful. (Not to mention well documented blackmail by Mahaney.) It is a sad commentary on “leadership” when they do nothing in the face of this evil and it is left to the lay-people to speak up and force change. As you know these leaders hold conferences attended by people from all over the world. Mahaney’s books are promoted at churches and Christian bookstores world-wide. John Folmar told me our church considers Mahaney’s books “go to books” for new Christians. We have had Dever, Trueman and DeYoung speak at our church. Dever, to the best of my knowledge, has not said anything positive or negative about Mahaney but he continues to share the platform with him at conferences. Trueman was a member of the original 3 man panel that declared Mahaney had not done anything to disqualify him from ministry. DeYoung has endorsed Mahaney. Piper will be speaking at our church later this year and he just spoke at Mahaney’s church and gave him a ringing endorsement. Mack Stiles preached at Mahaney’s church the week prior to Piper. Brent Detwiler said the following about John Piper, but I believe it applies to all these leaders:
“John has tolerated in SGM what he would never tolerate at Bethlehem Baptist Church. He has made exceptions for C.J. that he would never make for a church member.”
These leaders unwillingness to speak out against Mahaney, or tell him he needs to quit speaking at their conferences is doing untold damage to the Reformed movement world-wide. In April Duncan, Dever, DeYoung and Mahaney are jointly holding conferences in South Africa. The following blog from SA is questioning the whole Reformed movement, and I must add that I have read untold comments of the same sort. Reformed Christianity, which I believe holds to the correct scriptural doctrine, is taking a severe hit. I must admit that I myself am very disillusioned with the whole group of Reformed leaders. Again I will quote Detwiler:
It goes to show that godly men like Piper will disobey the Bible when idols in their hearts become more important than the righteousness of Christ and the truth of God. To be honest, it is hard to listen to some of these men preach any longer because of such hypocrisy. They protect their own, while their own harm others, and there are no consequences for their actions. In this way, they do not follow the Bible.
I agree with Detwiler. It is very hard for me to respect these leaders.
Religion that is pure and undefiled before God, the Father, is this: to visit orphans and widows in their affliction, and to keep oneself unstained from the world.
Over the past two years it has become evident that Brent Detwiler’s words also apply to John Folmar, the UCCD leadership and the leadership of several of the UCCD church plants in the United Arab Emirates.
Today and tomorrow Bruce Ware and Thomas Schreiner, both professors at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, will be holding a conference at UCCD. SBTS is the seminary where John Folmar studied. The president of the institute is C.J. Mahaney’s close friend Albert Mohler. Mohler has issued a strong statement of support for C.J. Mahaney. He has never retracted it. Bruce Ware and Thomas Schreiner both spoke from the pulpit of C.J. Mahaney’s run-away church plant in Louisville, KY. They all endorsed him in full knowledge of the sexual abuse scandal in the Sovereign Grace churches.
Nearly every conference speaker UCCD has had over the past several years has been an outspoken supporter of C.J. Mahaney. Coincidental? I think not. John Folmar has cast his lot with the Celebrity Christian “leadership” of the Neo-Reformed movement. He has chosen notoriety over identification with the weak and downtrodden.
Many UCCD members don’t know about these issues. Those that do have chosen not to confront John Folmar.
Earlier in the week I ran across this Tweet by Dave Furman. Furman is the senior pastor at Redeemer Church of Dubai, a church plant of UCCD. Furman is well aware of the Sovereign Grace/C.J. Mahaney scandal. I have had lengthy discussions with Mack Stiles, a senior leader at Redeemer, after he twice spoke at Mahaney’s church. Nevertheless, Furman also apparently has no issues featuring teachers who choose allegiance to the Gospel Glitterati over love and concern for the broken and abused sheep.
Notice the names of those who commented on Furman’s Tweet:
Thabiti Anyabwile – A close friend of John Folmar and Mark Dever. He has spoken at C.J. Mahaney’s run-away church plant, lending his support to the man.
Bryan DeWire – Formerly on staff of Desiring God Ministries, John Piper’s organization. Dewire now is the communications PR man for Sovereign Grace Ministries.
Matt Chandler – One of the Celebrity Christians riding the Christian Conference circuit, well established in the Gospel Corporation.
Sam Allberry – Well connected in the Gospel Corporation.
And so it goes. It really is a “good old boys” club where the main rule seems to be protect your fellow club members at all costs. To do so may cost you your integrity, but you will have notoriety and maybe even the money so many of them seem to be chasing.
Lydia's Corner: Exodus 12:14-13:16 Matthew 20:29-21:22 Psalm 25:16-22 Proverbs 6:12-15